A Must‑Stop Along Keuka Lake’s Route 54A: Q&A with Indian Pines Marketplace

Tucked along Route 54A near Keuka Lake, Indian Pines Marketplace is a roadside favorite that has been part of lake life for generations. What began in the 1950s as a self‑sustaining fruit stand has grown into a welcoming farm market and gift shop where you can grab fresh local produce, sandwiches, baked goods, and gifts from Finger Lakes makers before or after a day on the water. We caught up with owner, Launa Miller, to chat about the history and how Indian Pines has evolved throughout the years.

Indian Pines Farm Market has been a Penn Yan staple for decades. How would you describe the legacy of the old Indian Pines Fruit Stand and the role it plays in the community today?

Indian Pines started as a self‑sustaining fruit stand in the 1950s, with its own orchards producing peaches, apples, and grapes, plus grape pies and grape breads that people still talk about today. Over the years it has changed hands a few times, but the expectation has always stayed the same: amazing local fruits and vegetables for neighbors and visitors alike. I love seeing two or three generations at the counter sharing their memories of what the market “used to be,” and I feel a real responsibility to keep that tradition going while meeting the expectations of each new generation.

What inspired you to purchase Indian Pines Farm Market, and how have you put your own stamp on this long‑standing business while honoring its roots?

I was born and raised in Pennsylvania and visited Keuka Lake often growing up- first coming to Indian Pines through a wholesale evergreen connection that supplied Christmas trees to a previous owner. Those yearly holiday visits deepened my love for history and for places that make you feel like you’re walking back in time. My goal here is to preserve that feeling while putting my own stamp on the market: creating an ambiance that keeps people coming back and elevating local vendors and makers from around the lakes so Indian Pines feels like a true destination when you visit Keuka Lake.

Plan your stop at Indian Pines Farm Market in Penn Yan, NY, and check their current hours and directions.

For someone planning a Keuka Lake getaway who has never stopped at Indian Pines before, how would you describe the experience of walking into the market today?

When you walk into the market today, it feels a bit like stepping back in time, but with an unexpectedly wide variety of products catching your eye at every turn. I like to think of the market as “eye candy,” with little corners and nooks filled with different offerings that invite you to wander, explore, and discover something new. My aim is to make Indian Pines a one‑stop shop on Route 54A- somewhere you want to linger, browse, and return to throughout your stay on Keuka Lake.

Indian Pines has evolved from a traditional fruit stand into a full farm market and gift shop. What kinds of local products can visitors expect now, and how does that change with the Finger Lakes seasons?

At its core, Indian Pines is still all about fresh, local produce- fruits and vegetables are the first thing people expect when they stop in. We’ve always been known for breads and pies, and over time I’ve expanded the bakery and specialty offerings to meet the expectations of visitors from across the U.S. and beyond who come looking for both quality and variety.

Seasonally, the market changes with the Finger Lakes:

• Late spring and summer: We’re in the heart of sweet corn season, working closely with local growers who pick corn daily so we can maintain our reputation for exceptional, fresh sweet corn.
• Fall: We turn our focus to apples, ciders, and a variety of grapes from local grape growers, along with grape breads, pies, and grape‑based barbecue sauces from vendors like Arbor Hill.
• Holidays: We move into specialty pies for Thanksgiving and then Christmas trees, selling hundreds of trees in multiple varieties, sourced both locally and from Brown’s Tree Farm in Pennsylvania, plus handmade wreaths and fresh‑cut arrangements from local makers.

What is your philosophy as the current owner when it comes to supporting local Finger Lakes farmers, Mennonite producers, makers, and food businesses through Indian Pines?

I see Indian Pines as part of a wider community of small local businesses- farm stands, fruit stands, and markets all committed to local cropping, harvesting, and sustainability. For me, it’s less about formal partnerships and more about a shared vision built on pride, value, and taking care of the people who love the Finger Lakes. Visitors want quality products they can feel confident about (things that aren’t overly sprayed and are grown or made nearby) and my goal is for Indian Pines to be a place where those local producers are elevated and supported.

Indian Pines has called this stretch of Route 54A home for decades. What makes this corner of Yates County such a special place to run a farm market?

Location is everything! Indian Pines sits on a key stretch of Route 54A that acts as a gateway to this side of Keuka Lake. As drivers leave the village and head out of town, we’re one of the first places they see- and my goal is for Indian Pines to be the spot you have to stop at to pick up provisions, baked goods, and anything else you need for a week or weekend at the lake.

What do you personally find most unique about this area and how does that show up in the environment at Indian Pines Farm Market?

What I find most unique is how much there is to do here without a lot of big billboards or flashy advertising. People discover the area through conversations with friendly locals who love to share their favorite hidden spots—places like Spotted Duck, Tabora, and other small, off‑the‑map destinations where the scenic drive is part of the experience. At Indian Pines, those small‑town connections show up right at the counter, where we trade tips with customers about local stops and encourage them to breathe in the Finger Lakes, enjoy the views of Keuka Lake, and explore the many little markets, food stands, and wineries that make visits unforgettable.

Is Indian Pines Farm Market open year‑round, or does your schedule follow the growing and harvest seasons? What can visitors expect in early spring, peak summer, fall harvest, and around the holidays?

Indian Pines is seasonal. We open in late April and run seven days a week through Thanksgiving, with standard hours of 8:30AM to 5:00PM and slightly earlier Sunday closing so our staff can spend time with their families. During the Christmas season, we reopen on a seven‑day schedule to accommodate tree and wreath shoppers, so Indian Pines can be part of both your summer traditions and your holiday ones.

Looking ahead, what do you see on the horizon for Indian Pines- any new offerings, events, or experiences you’re excited to offer?

One of the most exciting recent additions is our deli, which now offers breakfast sandwiches made with Timberline smoked meats; giving morning visitors another reason to stop along Route 54A. We also serve assorted lunch sandwiches, including a fantastic caprese option, and salad bowls built on Misty Meadow lettuce from Canandaigua, tying everyday offerings back to local producers. Looking ahead, I plan to grow both the bakery and deli lines with specialty meats and cheeses and a few surprises that will roll out over time, giving people even more reasons to make Indian Pines a must‑stop on Keuka Lake.